Selling a rental property? How a 1031 exchange into a DST can defer the tax
The call started with a question.
A client asked "We are thinking about selling Dad's house and reinvesting the money. What are your thoughts?"
Their dad bought a single family home in the 1980s and has rented it out ever since. He's getting older, so they started helping. First with his investments, then with the house itself.
The house had become a lot to manage. Bad tenants, then another round of bad tenants. The rent kept coming in, but so did the calls and the repairs. Twice was enough. They were ready to be done.
Two things kept them from selling.
The first was taxes. Dad owned the house for about 40 years. The sale price would be around $1.2 million. Their accountant tracked the depreciation and everything Dad put back into the house, and put the gain at about $800,000.
If Dad sells outright, he owes tax on that gain. The part that comes from depreciation can be taxed at up to 25% federally. The rest is taxed at long-term capital gains rates, plus a 3.8% net investment income tax for higher earners. The house is in California, which taxes capital gains as ordinary income. On a gain this size, the bill is large.
The second was income. The rent was still paying Dad every month. If they sold, would he still have enough coming in?
The two options they could see
They saw two choices. Keep the house and keep dealing with tenants. Or sell, pay the tax, and invest what's left in the stock market.
Both are legitimate. In my experience, investing in the market is simple as long as you can sit through the swings. Selling outright also lets you reach your money whenever you need it, and the costs can be lower than what I describe below.
For this family, both choices had a price. Keeping the house meant keeping the tenants. Selling meant paying a large tax bill to the IRS and California up front, and replacing a monthly rent payment with a portfolio Dad would draw income from.
The first question I asked
Before we talked about strategy, I asked what they wanted this money to do? Income? Preservation? Something else?
They said both. Income for Dad, and preservation of what he had built.
That answer shaped everything I looked at next. With a tax bill that size, we started talking about a third option.
How a 1031 exchange works
A 1031 exchange is named for Section 1031 of the tax code. You sell investment real estate and roll the proceeds into other investment real estate. You can defer the tax on your gain instead of paying it the year you sell.
The word that matters is defer. The tax carries into the new property and can come due later if you eventually sell without doing another exchange.
The rules are strict.
You have 45 days from the sale to identify your replacement property in writing.
You have 180 days from the sale to close on it, or until your tax return is due for that year if that comes first. Filing an extension can get you the full 180.
The proceeds go to a qualified intermediary, a third party who holds the money during the exchange. If the cash lands in your account, the exchange can fail.
To defer all of the tax, you generally need to reinvest all of the proceeds into property of equal or greater value. Anything you take out, called "boot," can be taxed.
California adds one more step. If you exchange California property for property in another state, you file a form with California every year (FTB 3840). When the new property is eventually sold in a taxable sale, California can still collect its tax on the gain you deferred.
Most people hear "1031" and picture selling one rental to buy another. For this family, that would have missed the point. They wanted out of being landlords.
Where a DST fits
A Delaware Statutory Trust, or DST, lets you own a fractional interest in a larger, professionally managed property, like a big apartment community or a medical office building. The IRS has ruled that a properly structured DST interest can count as replacement real estate in a 1031 exchange (Revenue Ruling 2004-86).
For this family, that spoke to both concerns. Dad's gain could stay deferred. His share of the trust is designed to pay distributions. And the sponsor handles the tenants and the repairs.
A DST also comes with real tradeoffs.
It's hard to get out of. DST interests aren't publicly traded. Holding periods often run 5 to 10 years, and selling early can be difficult.
You give up control. The sponsor makes the decisions on managing, financing, and eventually selling the property. Your results depend on how well they run it.
The income isn't guaranteed. Distributions can be reduced or stopped if the property struggles, and the property itself can lose value.
There are fees. Acquisition, management, and disposition fees can reduce what you receive.
Not everyone qualifies. DSTs are generally limited to accredited investors.
The structure has its own rules. If a DST doesn't follow the IRS's restrictions, the tax deferral itself could be at risk.
What else I looked at
I looked at a lot of options before landing on the DST.
Their preservation goal sent me first to principal protected notes and market linked CDs. Both have limits. The protection generally holds only if you keep them to maturity, a principal protected note is only as strong as the company that issues it, and the upside is often capped. I also looked at REITs and 721 exchanges, among other things.
The notes, the CDs, and REIT shares would all have meant selling outright and paying the tax first. Dad would have started over with a smaller amount of money.
A 721 exchange keeps the tax deferred by trading real estate for units in a REIT's operating partnership. Those units generally can't be exchanged into real estate again, and converting them to REIT shares triggers the tax you put off.
With the tax bill this family was facing, the DST fit best. It kept all of the sale proceeds invested, and it is designed to pay income.
It does not protect principal. The property can lose value, and that works against their preservation goal.
For them, the trade was worth considering. They gave up liquidity and control over a property they were trying to get away from anyway. For someone who might need that money back in 3 years, the same move could be the wrong one.
If you're one of the kids
The people on the phone with me were Dad's adult kids, helping an aging parent decide what to do with something he built. If that's you, there's a tax rule you should know.
Under current law, inherited property generally gets a "step up in basis." For tax purposes, it's treated as if the heirs bought it at its value on the date of death. The built up gain, including depreciation, can be reset. That can apply to property held through a 1031 exchange too.
So the timing of a sale can matter more as a parent gets older. That's a conversation for you, your parent, your CPA, and an estate attorney, and it should happen before the house is listed.
What I took from this
When they called, they had already decided there were two options. Most of my job was showing them there were more, and it started with one question. What do you want this money to do?
Picking where the money goes is the easy part. Listening long enough to hear everything going on takes more time. They were tired, worried about the tax bill, and worried about whether Dad would be okay.
A 1031 exchange into a DST is one tool, and each situation is unique so it may or may not be a good fit for your situation. If you own a rental you've held for decades and you assume the only way out is a big tax bill, ask yourself a few things first.
What do you need that money to do for you?
How much do you depend on that rent check?
Could you leave the money tied up for 5 to 10 years?
Who will be making decisions about this property 10 years from now?
Thinking about selling a rental property? Talk to someone before you list it.
If you're weighing the sale of a rental, for yourself or for a parent, let's talk before it goes on the market. A 1031 exchange has to be set up before the sale closes, and once it closes, the 45-day clock is already running.
We just need to know the year the property was bought, a rough idea of what it's worth, and how much rent it brings in. We'll look at which options fit your situation. Contact us at info@paritycap.com or (702) 463-0063.
---
This material is for educational purposes only and is not tax or legal advice. 1031 exchanges are subject to strict IRS requirements, and tax laws may change. Investments in Delaware Statutory Trusts involve risks, including illiquidity, loss of principal, lack of control, and fees; distributions are not guaranteed. DSTs are generally available only to accredited investors. Please consult your tax and legal advisors about your specific situation. Client details are shared with permission.
Securities and investment advisory services offered through Osaic Wealth, Inc. member FINRA/SIPC. Osaic Wealth is separately owned and other entities and/or marketing names, products or services referenced here are independent of Osaic Wealth.
Comments